Tackling the Constraints on EU Foreign Policy towards Ukraine: From Strategic Denial to Geopolitical Awakening
This report explores the evolution of EU policy towards Ukraine, with major turning points occurring in 2004, 2014 and February 2022 when Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine started. The dominant constraining factor in the case of Ukraine was multipolar (or rather bipolar) competition between the EU and Russia over the European political, economic and security order, which gradually tightened since 2004. Up to 2022, the EU’s main mitigation tactics in response to such competition was actually a denial of it, but in 2022 this approach became untenable and the EU entered the competition as an emerging geopolitical actor, actively trying to shape the future of European order that was challenged by the war in Ukraine. EU–Ukraine relations were also complicated by regional fragmentation in the post-Soviet space and within Ukraine, but this factor was overshadowed by geopolitical competition. Intra-EU contestation was an important constraining factor in 2004–2014, but after 2014 and especially after 2022 the EU reached an unprecedented level of unity in the face of the most serious geopolitical conflict in post-WWII Europe.
-
Details
Rome, IAI, April 2023, 50 p. -
In:
-
Issue
JOINT Research Paper 20
Introduction
1. The constraints on EU foreign and security policy
2. EU policy towards Ukraine: Strategy and execution
2.1 Stage 1 (1991–2004): Barely on the EU’s radar
2.2 Stage 2 (2004–2014): Upgrading relations with new Eastern neighbours
2.3 Stage 3 (2014–2022): In denial of tightening geopolitical competition
2.4 Stage 4 (2022–present): The awakening of a geopolitical Union
3. The constraints on EU Ukraine policy
3.1 Tightening multipolar competition
3.2 Regional fragmentation
3.3 Intra-EU contestation
4. The EU’s responses to constraints: From mitigation tactics to geopolitical actorness
4.1 Denial of multipolar competition
4.2 Multilateralisation and minilateralisation
4.3 Supporting Ukraine’s reforms and resilience
4.4 Stretching the limits of EU toolbox
5. Conclusions and policy recommendations: A new, geopolitical EU taking shape after Russia’s full-scale invasion
References